Failure to communicate: Army wife’s collection heavy on stereotypes, short on joy
Posted : Sunday Mar 6, 2011 17:20:44 EST
Siobhan Fallon’s collection of fictional stories about the drama surrounding soldiers and spouses at Fort Hood, Texas, is beautifully written. An Army spouse herself, Fallon saturates the work with details that build a colorful picture of her characters.
The eight stories involve a group of recurring characters involved in distinct narratives. One story details the battle of an injured Army specialist redeploying to a wife set on divorcing him. He returns in the book’s final story, which examines a war widow’s struggle to sort through her untimely loss.
Book review: You Know When the Men Are Gone
By Siobhan Fallon; Amy Einhorn Books, 240 pages; $23.95.
I was surprised by how much I enjoyed the book. Prior to reading it, I heard a radio interview with Fallon in which the reporter focused many of his questions on the subject of infidelity in the military, which, as an Army spouse, I believe is greatly overplayed in the civilian media.
Regardless, I felt completely wrapped up in the lives of Fallon’s characters, frantically turning the pages to discover their fates. The first story, after which the book is titled, sets the stage for an insider’s view of the darkest challenges of military life.
Meg, an Army wife at Fort Hood, struggles with her feelings toward her new spouse-neighbor, a Serbian immigrant who speaks very little English. Meg in turns obsesses over, eavesdrops on, hates, helps and avoids her neighbor as they both navigate the challenges of deployment.
But despite really enjoying most of the stories, I still turned to the final page with a sense of disgust. Fallon’s sin here is one of omission. While her stories are entertaining, they present to civilian readers a perfect picture of worst-case-scenario Army life but include nothing of the good.
She paints only in extremes and ignores almost entirely the comparatively frequent triumphs and joys we experience. Where are the stories about the pride of being a military family or the resiliency that characterizes most military spouses and their relationships?
Six of her eight stories deal specifically with divorce, cheating spouses or crumbling marriages. Sure, tales of grief, hardship and scandal make entertaining reading and play into existing stereotypes.
But as a military spouse, I’m disappointed that Fallon does not feel a responsibility to give civilian society an accurate picture of military family life. The things we do to get by in a time of war go far beyond worrying obsessively about a cheating spouse or obnoxious neighbor — a truth Fallon fails to communicate.
Leave a Comment
Most Viewed Stories
- Report: Bragg 1-star removed from position
- Reservist’s death in Afghanistan ruled suicide
- Dwindling budget forces changes to mess halls
- Family of soldier to receive Medal of Honor
- Combat jobs open to female soldiers this week
- Bragg staff sgt. dies after police shooting
- Command leadership tours capped at 24 months
- Hawaii-based soldier killed in Afghanistan
- National parks entrance fees waived for troops
- Allen may depart Afghanistan for Europe post
- Army seeks new recruiting, training strategies
- Overseas shipping of many electronics banned
Contests and Promotions
Free Stickers
Click here and we'll send you a FREE AFGHANISTAN, IRAQ, VIETNAM, or DESERT STORM sticker.
Marketplaces
Industry
MIl-MALL
Browse and buy some of the awesome products we have at Mil-mall.com
-
Gummi Army Guys
Price: $1.25
Add to Cart | See More Products! -
Sniper Brew Classic Roast Coffee
Price: $9.95
Add to Cart | See More Products! -
The Hooah! button
Price: $9.95
Add to Cart | See More Products! -
SNIPER: American Single-Shot Warriors in Iraq and Afghanistan
Price: $16.95
Add to Cart | See More Products! -
Army Scrapbook Album
Price: $9.95
Add to Cart | See More Products! -
VALOR and VISION: Heroes * Leaders * Innovation
Price: $6.95
Add to Cart | See More Products!
Military Discounts
Save on your purchases!
In honor of your military service, you can find regular and name brand products at a special discount.










