Master Sgt. Joe Klingbeil wanted to vote in Kentucky’s primary this year. But he was in Germany, where he had volunteered for an assignment as an Army reservist.

Klingbeil registered to vote absentee and asked for a ballot from the Bullitt County Board of Elections. 

He said it never came.

“I never received a mail-in ballot, so I didn’t get to vote in the primaries. I was a little salty about that,” Klingbeil said.

For the 2026 midterm general election, Klingbeil was determined not to let it happen again.

While home in Kentucky on leave in September, he visited the Bullitt County Clerk’s office, where he was told a ballot mailed directly to Germany might not reach him with enough time for him to return it, as the verification process for sending a ballot to Germany would take longer. 

So Klingbeil and his family devised another plan, one designed to track the ballot step by step: It  would be mailed to his home in Kentucky, where his son would retrieve the ballot and then mail it to Germany.

“My son got it and immediately went up to the post office and mailed it here to me,” Klingbeil said.

Klingbeil received the ballot Oct. 8. Five days later, he returned the ballot by mail. It had to cross the Atlantic Ocean twice.

Kentucky will not count an overseas military ballot that arrives after polls close on Election Day. It is one of 20 U.S. states with no grace period for an overseas military ballot that was mailed on time but arrives afterward to be counted. 

Klingbeil hoped his ballot would arrive on time but noted that if it didn’t, “then apparently my vote is not going to count.”

Klingbeil had good reason to worry. In the last major election he could vote in, thousands of service members’ ballots went uncounted. 

At least 7,200 of more than 223,000 absentee military ballots were rejected in the 2024 presidential election alone, according to an analysis of the federal Election Administration and Voting Survey by the Howard Centers for Investigative Journalism at Arizona State University and the University of Maryland, in partnership with the Military Times and The Beam. Of the rejected ballots, 55% were turned down for missing the deadline. The survey relies on local election officials to report their numbers, and not every jurisdiction reports each cycle.  

While every state lets military voters return ballots by mail, options such as email, fax and online systems vary by state. Only 26 states and the District of Columbia allow overseas uniformed service members to return a ballot by email or through an online portal.

The result is a patchwork system in which two service members facing the same deployment conditions can have very different chances to have their vote count — based on the state they call home.

Klingbeil was not the only service member deployed abroad this November determined to have his vote counted. Sarah Streyder runs Secure Families Initiative, a nonpartisan advocacy organization for military families, and she said its voting outreach program saw high-call volume, reflecting a high interest in voting. She pointed to the issues motivating American families being important to military voters as well.

“But you add onto that a layer of us being at war right now,” Streyder said, “it was a huge motivator.”

Federal law requires states to let eligible military and overseas voters cast absentee ballots. The Uniformed and Overseas Citizens Absentee Voting Act, passed in 1986, requires states to provide absentee voting for eligible military and overseas voters. The Military and Overseas Voter Empowerment Act later required states to transmit requested absentee ballots to those voters at least 45 days before a federal election.

But that doesn’t mean overseas voters’ ballots are being counted. 

“Of course, tragically, you still have the problem of there being bases and carriers not receiving mail,” Streyder said.

Nowhere has the problem been more persistent than in Duval County, home to Jacksonville, Florida. In each of the last three elections analyzed by the Howard Centers, it ranked either first or second nationally in rejected military ballots. Its percentage of military ballots rejected also exceeded the national rate in all three elections. 

Duval County rejected 302 military ballots in 2024 alone.

Philip McCrary’s ballot was one of them.

McCrary said records showed his ballot as received at 11 a.m. on Election Day in 2024. It was nevertheless later marked as too late. 

“Being in the service, I miss most elections due to operational commitments, out of country or delays in the mail,” McCrary said. “I’d say most service members do not have their voices heard in voting. Depending on the assignment, mail can take weeks or months to get to you or from you.”

Among states, Florida stands out for its volume of rejected ballots. Across three election cycles since 2020, Florida has rejected at least 5,000 ballots, according to the Howard Centers’ analysis. Six states did not have complete data.

The Florida Division of Elections did not provide comment on the Howard Centers’ findings on the state’s high number of overseas-military ballot rejections across recent elections.

When ballots arrive too late

For deployed troops, the difference among state laws becomes most consequential when the military sends them somewhere the available voting methods do not work easily.

That happened this spring.

As fighting between the U.S. and Iran disrupted transportation across the Gulf region, postal service was suspended to military post offices in the Middle East and Europe. At some military locations, mail service was unavailable for months. As of mid-October, four military post offices in Europe and the Middle East were still suspended, according to the U.S. Postal Service.

For one service member registered to vote in California, the disruption coincided with the state’s June 2 primary.

Speaking to the Howard Center under anonymity while she is still on active duty, the service member said this meant searching for a way to cast her ballot in her state’s primary election without access to a postal service. As a registered voter in California, state law only permits a ballot return through postal mail or fax.

In early April, she emailed the Federal Voting Assistance Program, the Defense Department office that helps military and overseas voters, asking what options were available to someone in her situation without access to any ballot return method.

She received a routine response explaining how to request an absentee ballot and how to return it. Her original question of what contingency options were available was not answered.

“Once I received my email back confirming my only option was mailing back my ballot, I then brought this up to my direct leadership,” she said. “They attempted to push up the problem to the brigade and division level, but we never got a resolution. No one I knew or deployed with was able to vote in the primaries.”

The service member said her unit had no assigned Voting Assistance Officer, the military personnel designated to help troops navigate the voting process. 

But a Voting Assistance Officer could not change the central problem she faced: California law determined how she could return her ballot. Her deployment had cut her off from options she could use.

Howard Center reporters obtained information about military voters whose ballots were rejected in Duval County, Florida, in the 2024 general election. Reporters sent emails to about 150 voters asking two questions; 1.) Were you aware that your ballot was not counted in the 2024 election? 2.) What was the process like trying to vote while you were out of state?

Other military voters contacted by the Howard Centers described confusion not only about why their ballots were rejected, but when election officials had received them.

One voter, who preferred to remain anonymous due to an active-duty status, did not have a ballot counted although the voter believed it arrived before Election Day. 

“I was aware that my ballot was not counted in 2024, at the time, I was disappointed,” the voter said in an email to the Howard Center. “My ballot was received by Florida on time, but there was some sort of mix-up. My ballot was delivered before the due date, but for some reason it was never processed.”

The voter reached out to the Duval County Supervisor of Elections Office for answers shortly after the election, and a staff member in the office’s Voter Services Division, Maggie Johnson, told the voter that the ballot was received Nov. 6 — the day after the 2024 general election. The voter claimed their ballot was marked delivered by the postal service on Nov. 3, two days before Election Day.

“It just took us that long to finally return all of these late ones because we were doing other post-election activities in the process,” Johnson said in a voicemail message to the voter.

The Howard Centers asked the Duval County Supervisor of Elections about its ranking as No. 1 in 2022 and No. 2 in 2024 for UOCAVA uniformed service member ballot rejections, according to the Howard Center’s original data analysis. The office did not provide comment on the ranking of Duval County among UOCAVA ballot rejections.

When reporters asked if there had been changes made to the ballot receipt process for the 2026 election to ensure ballots that arrive before the deadline are counted, Johnson said, “Our current processes already ensure that every ballot that arrives within the deadline is counted if the signature matches.”

Florida has a 10-day grace period in place for overseas ballots. 

State Sen. Barbara Sharief, who represents the state’s 35th District outside Fort Lauderdale, Florida, and sits on the Senate’s Military and Veterans Affairs, Space and Domestic Security Committee, said the state could do better. 

In a written response, Sharief said the state legislature “should be working toward a system where every eligible voter has a meaningful opportunity to cast a ballot and have that ballot counted. Our military personnel put their lives on the line defending our constitutional freedoms. We should be doing everything reasonably possible to protect their constitutional right to vote.”

The military’s part

The Defense Department has taken steps to give service members more help and more time to vote.

In an Oct. 1 memo, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth ordered commanders to conduct a one-day voting stand-down during October of every even-numbered year, beginning this year. 

But time away from normal duties does not necessarily solve the logistical problems confronting voters overseas. 

In Germany, Klingbeil questioned what a stand-down could accomplish for someone whose only practical option was an absentee ballot sent by mail.

“Honestly, I don’t know if we would even warrant [a stand down] since we can’t vote over here,” Klingbeil said. “We can’t go to the polls or anything like that.” 

The distinction points to the limits of the military’s role. Commanders and Voting Assistance Officers can provide information, reminders and assistance. They cannot change the return methods or receipt deadlines established by a service member’s home state.

One Duval County voter said the assistance arrived too late.

“By the time the command rep actually informs everyone, it’s already too late to vote in Florida,” The Duval County voter said. “So for me, the voting assistance didn’t assist me at all. The least they could do was remind me before it was too late.”

What could change

Americans turned out in record numbers for this year’s midterms. Alberto Ramos, CEO of Veterans for All Voters, a nonprofit organization that advocates for greater voter enfranchisement, wondered whether service members benefited from exercising their right to vote.

“As we celebrate participation across the country, we should ask whether that participation reached the people serving it,” Ramos said.

Ramos, who served as a Voting Assistance Officer while in the Navy, sees room for improvement.

“ When you’re on a ship, you’ve got your main job, and then you’ve got, like, 10 collateral duties,” Ramos said. “ I know that there are commands where the VAO isn’t as plugged in, or that’s the one of 10 collateral duties that they pay less attention to.”

Ultimately, the military will handle assisting service members in line with federal law. It is the states that have the responsibility to ensure voters have the means to exercise their constitutional right to vote.

“We should have states exploring mobile voting and electronic ballot return,” Ramos said. “Even if it’s by fax or email, that’s an improvement to having to send off a letter. And even if you’re still voting by mail, it’s having reasonable grace periods so that your ballot has time to make it back to your state.”

In the last 15 years, FVAP has spent more than $47.9 million on its Effective Absentee Systems for Elections grants for states across the country to research improvements for military and overseas voters. 

The grants have helped states such as Arizona and Nevada, which have since implemented an electronic ballot system for absentee voters.  

California lawmakers considered legislation this year that would have expanded secure electronic ballot transmission for military and overseas voters. SB 970 advanced through the Legislature before Assemblymember Robert Garcia placed it on the inactive file.  

Los Angeles County Assistant Registrar-Recorder Aaron Nevarez said the bill was a positive step toward expanding voting access for absentee service members, even though it was shelved.

Nevarez is a member of the Overseas Voting Initiative, a working group aimed at expanding voting access for UOCAVA voters.

“A lot of the concerns around this bill, from what we’ve heard from legislators and especially our Secretary of State’s office, have been on security,” Nevarez said.

Nevarez has been a part of a push in California to expand voting capabilities using electronic voting in California.

“One of the biggest things that I see, and you look at the data from states that have electronic return, you see higher turnout,” Nevarez said. “Our service members are out there putting their life on the line so we can have this franchise. We should do everything in our power to make it as accessible as possible for them to get their ballots back.”

Exactly a week before Election Day, Klingbiel received good news: His ballot was received by his county clerk.

“I was getting worried there that the system may have failed me, but I’m kind of a pessimist when it comes to things like that,” he said. “Anyways, [I’m feeling] relief. I hope that it was accepted.”

A more complete picture of service member participation in this year’s midterm elections – and ballot return and rejection rates – will not be known until county and state data becomes available, which could take more than a year.